Galaxies without dark matter: evidence and debates.
The discovery of galaxies without dark matter has sparked exciting debates. Dark matter was once seen as key in galaxy formation. But, since 2018, especially with NGC 1052-DF2, this view has changed.
This article will look into galaxies without dark matter. We’ll explore their features and the mysteries of their creation.
Galaxies like NGC 1052-DF4 are also being studied. In 2020, a team found 19 dwarf galaxies that might not have dark matter. This evidence makes us question how galaxies form in a universe mostly made of dark matter.
Let’s dive into the world of galaxies without dark matter. We’ll uncover the science behind these cosmic wonders.
Introduction to Galaxies and Dark Matter
Galaxies are huge groups of stars, gas, and complex structures. They are the basic parts of our universe. A key part of this is how galaxies and dark matter are connected. Learning about this starts with understanding galaxies.
Most galaxies have a lot of dark matter. This matter is vital for their growth and balance.
What is dark matter? It’s a mysterious substance that doesn’t react with light. It makes up about 27% of the universe’s mass. Dark matter’s role in galaxies is huge.
It keeps galaxies together through gravity. This is shown in computer simulations.
The galaxies and dark matter relationship helps us understand the universe. The Bullet Cluster shows most mass is around galaxies, not in stars or gas. This shows the universe is mostly dark matter, about 84%.
Dark matter is key to knowing how galaxies form and change. It’s essential for understanding the universe’s layout, from galaxy clusters to our local area.
Understanding Dark Matter’s Role in Cosmic Structure
Dark matter plays a key role in shaping our universe. It makes up about 85% of all matter. This invisible matter pulls visible matter towards it, helping galaxies form.
Dark matter is much more common than regular matter, with a ratio of more than 5:1. It’s crucial for the gravitational pull that brings stars and galaxies together.
Galaxies grow as ordinary matter clumps together, pulled by dark matter halos. These halos help create galaxies and shape their structure over time. Studies show that dark matter is needed to explain the universe’s gravity, as regular matter alone can’t account for it.
Since the 1930s, scientists have found evidence of dark matter. Pioneers like Fritz Zwicky and Vera Rubin have made big contributions. The way galaxies are spread out in the universe shows how dark matter works.
| Aspect | Details |
|---|---|
| Composition | Dark matter constitutes approximately 85% of total matter in the universe. |
| Mass Ratio | It accounts for more than five times the amount of all ordinary matter combined. |
| Gravitational Impact | Gravitational measurements indicate that observed gravity exceeds predictions by five times. |
| Candidate Particles | WIMPs may range from 1 to 1,000 times the mass of a proton. |
| Historical Evidence | Research and observational evidence have evolved since the 1930s. |
| Distribution of Galaxies | Galaxies are often identified along filamentary structures with empty voids in between. |
Dark matter’s impact on the universe is huge. It helps us understand how galaxies form. As we learn more, we’ll uncover more about this mysterious part of our universe.
The Discovery of Galaxies without Dark Matter
The discovery of galaxies without dark matter is a big step forward in space research. NGC 1052-DF2 was the first galaxy found to have only normal matter. This finding changed how we think about how galaxies form. It happened in 2018 with the help of the Hubble Space Telescope’s advanced imaging.
Then, NGC 1052-DF4 was found, showing that galaxies with little dark matter do exist. This discovery goes against old ideas that dark matter is more common than normal matter. For a long time, scientists thought dark matter made up about 5 times more of the universe than normal matter.
The universe started very evenly, with only a 0.003% difference from the average. This evenness was key to understanding how the universe grew. But, finding galaxies like NGC 1052-DF2 and NGC 1052-DF4 shows that the universe is always changing.
It’s rare to find galaxies where dark matter is much less than normal matter. These discoveries make us rethink how galaxies are made. They show that the universe’s galaxies are more varied than we thought.
| Galaxy | Composition | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| NGC 1052-DF2 | 100% Normal Matter | First known dark-matter-free galaxy |
| NGC 1052-DF4 | Minimal Dark Matter | Confirmation of dark-matter-free galaxies |
| NGC 1277 | Up to 5% Dark Matter | Remarkable relic galaxy with unexpected dark matter content |
Studying these unique galaxies makes us rethink how the universe works. Seeing galaxies without dark matter changes our models. It shows how complex the universe really is.
Analyzing the Characteristics of Dark-Matter-Free Galaxies
Dark-matter-free galaxies, like NGC 1052-DF2, show unique traits that change how we see galaxy makeup. A study looked at 214 galaxies to check their mass and light. Amazingly, 62% had no big difference between their mass and light.
The other galaxies had an average density of about 14 solar masses per square parsec. This density comes from red dwarf stars, stellar remnants, and other matter. The makeup of these galaxies makes us wonder how they form and grow.
The study also found that star mass gets smaller as you move from the center to the edges of these galaxies. This suggests that faint, low-mass stars are common in the outer parts.
NGC 1052-DF2 has interesting dynamics. For example, the speed between galaxies DF2 and DF4 is 358 km/s, much faster than the NGC 1052 group. The galaxies are about 2.1 ± 0.5 Mpc apart, far beyond NGC 1052’s radius. This shows they followed different paths after colliding, about 8 billion years ago.
This study on galaxy dynamics highlights the unique features of NGC 1052-DF2 characteristics and their role in dark-matter-free galaxy formation. The way the galaxies are arranged suggests a linear pattern, which is very significant. This pattern encourages more research into how galaxies form and evolve.
Proposed Mechanisms for the Formation of Dark-Matter-Free Galaxies
The study of dark-matter-free galaxies shows interesting galaxy formation mechanisms. These findings challenge what we thought we knew. Cosmic collisions might remove dark matter from galaxies, especially when they meet larger ones.
Also, smaller galaxies often make new stars. This process can push out normal matter, leaving behind dark matter. This shows that these galaxies have their own special paths in the universe.
Studies have found 324 galaxy clusters in simulations. These include the dwarf galaxy NGC 1052-DF2 and the massive NGC 1277. These examples help us understand why some galaxies have less dark matter than expected.
Research shows that the amount of dark matter in a galaxy can change based on several factors. For instance, the number of orbits and the distance at pericentres matter. Studies by Yu et al. (2018) and Saulder et al. (2020) found that dark matter-deficient galaxies are not rare. They are more common in areas with many massive galaxies.
Evidence Supporting the Existence of Dark-Matter-Free Galaxies
Recent observational studies have greatly added to the evidence for dark-matter-free galaxies. A key example is AGC 114905, an ultra-diffuse dwarf galaxy about 250 million light-years away. It’s as big as the Milky Way but has 1,000 times fewer stars.
Scientists used the Very Large Array (VLA) telescope for 40 hours in 2020. They studied AGC 114905 and found its gas rotation can be explained by normal matter alone. This means no dark matter is needed to understand its movement.
This discovery questions the old idea that all galaxies are held together by dark matter. To explain AGC 114905 without dark matter, scientists would have to use extreme values. This is different from what we usually see.
Now, scientists are looking at another ultra-diffuse dwarf galaxy. They want to learn more about dark matter. These studies are changing how we think about the universe and how galaxies grow.
Debates within the Scientific Community
The discovery of galaxies without dark matter has caused big debates among astrophysicists. They question the accuracy of early findings and what they mean for dark matter theories. As scientists study these galaxies more, they wonder how they formed and if old galaxy formation theories need to be updated.
These debates remind us of the Great Debate in 1920. It was about the nature of spiral nebulae and the size of the Universe. Today, scientists are thinking if dark-matter-free galaxies mean we need new theories that change how we see the Universe.
New discoveries are making scientists rethink their views of the Universe. These debates will likely lead to new ideas and models. This could change how we see galaxies and their role in the dark matter and cosmic structure.
| Aspect | Traditional Views | Emerging Theories |
|---|---|---|
| Existence of Dark Matter | Essential for galaxy formation and stability | Dark-matter-free galaxies challenge this notion |
| Measurement Techniques | Standard practices using luminosity | New methods may be required to account for anomalies |
| Implications for Galaxy Models | Assumed universal presence of dark matter | Potential revisions in models of cosmic evolution |
Comparing Dark-Matter-Rich and Dark-Matter-Free Galaxies
Dark-matter-rich galaxies and their dark-matter-free counterparts show big differences. These differences are seen in their structure and how they evolve. Dark-matter-rich galaxies usually have a 5:1 ratio of dark matter to normal matter, as most models suggest.
For example, NGC 1277 is much bigger than the Milky Way but has only about 5% dark matter within 20,000 light-years. Theories say galaxies of similar mass should have at least 10% to 70% dark matter.
On the other hand, dark-matter-free galaxies have stars that match their visible mass. Take NGC 1052-DF2 and DF4 as examples. These galaxies are made only of normal matter, showing new galaxy characteristics that question how galaxies form.
Studies using integral field spectrography have shown that some low-mass galaxies might not have dark matter. This changes how we think about the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation. It shows that galaxy behavior can be predicted by normal matter alone.
| Galaxy Type | Dark Matter Ratio | Mass Characteristics | Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dark-Matter-Rich Galaxy | 5:1 | Contains up to 70% dark matter | Various locations |
| Dark-Matter-Free Galaxy | 0:1 | Entirely normal matter | NGC 1052-DF2, DF4, NGC 1277 |
| Ultra Diffuse Galaxy | 30:1 | High mass-to-light ratio | Various clusters |
| Dwarf Galaxies | Exceeding 5:1 | Increased dark matter presence | Common in low-density regions |
There’s growing interest in studying how galaxies formed early on. The unique features of dark-matter-free galaxies encourage more research. These comparisons of galaxies show not just differences in makeup but also highlight the various forces shaping their paths through time.
Future Research Directions and Questions
The search for how galaxies form is about to reveal a lot. Scientists are looking into dark matter, especially in galaxies without it. They want to know how common these galaxies are and what they mean for the universe.
New tools like the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) are helping us see more. These tools will give us a better view of how galaxies form in the next 10 to 20 years.
The Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) also plays a big role. It helps us understand the universe’s early days. The Euclid telescope will help us learn more about the universe’s structure and dark matter.
New models are being made to better understand galaxy formation. They include baryonic physics, which is important. Looking into dark matter’s properties could link particle physics and cosmology. This will help us understand the universe better.
| Research Focus | Potential Impact | Timeframe |
|---|---|---|
| Formation mechanisms of dark-matter-free galaxies | Clarify their prevalence and implications | 1-5 years |
| Advancements in observational technology | Increase understanding of galaxy structures | Next 10-20 years |
| Utilization of the CMB data | Improve models of thermal equilibrium | 5-10 years |
| Investigation of baryonic physics | Enhance replication of galaxy formation | Ongoing |
| Exploration of non-standard dark matter | Bridge gaps between particle physics and cosmology | 5-15 years |
Conclusion
The discovery of galaxies without dark matter is a big challenge to our current understanding of the universe. About 25% of galaxies we see don’t have dark matter. This has made scientists very interested in this area again.
For example, early-type galaxies show a big difference between the matter we can see and dark matter. This suggests that these galaxies formed in complex ways. It could change how we think about how galaxies move and grow.
Looking at exceptions like NGC 1052-DF2 and NGC 1052-DF4, we see big questions about our current understanding of the universe. Research shows that in some places, up to 35% of mass doesn’t fit into our dark matter models. This makes our current models seem too simple.
Studies also show that about 10% of galaxies in similar places have very little dark matter. This challenges what we thought we knew. It shows us there’s still a lot to learn.
Exploring galaxies without dark matter helps us understand different types of galaxies better. It also leads to talks about new theories, like modified gravity for about 12% of these galaxies. This research is changing how we see the universe and could lead to big discoveries.
FAQ
What are galaxies without dark matter?
How was the existence of dark-matter-free galaxies discovered?
What implications do dark-matter-free galaxies have on our understanding of the universe?
Are there theories about how dark-matter-free galaxies form?
What evidence supports the existence of dark-matter-free galaxies?
What debates are happening within the scientific community regarding dark-matter-free galaxies?
How do dark-matter-rich and dark-matter-free galaxies differ?
What future research is planned regarding dark-matter-free galaxies?
